About the Author

Author: Justin Nabity

Last updated: October 5, 2026

Financial Planning | Manage Your Money | Tax Planning

Tax Problems Physicians Face (and How to Fix Them)

Key Takeaways

  • Most physician tax problems come from withholding and planning gaps, and very few come from the tax rates themselves.
  • Bonuses, second jobs, and two-income households are the usual reasons a physician owes money in April.
  • Your top bracket only applies to your last dollars of income, so your real rate is lower than it looks.
  • Side income paid on a 1099 has no tax taken out, which means quarterly estimated payments are on you.
  • Tax planning done during the year saves more than anything your preparer can do at filing time.

If you feel like you have tax problems, you’re in good company. Taxes are the single largest expense most physicians will ever have, bigger than the house and bigger than the student loans.

And the frustrating part is how it shows up. You get a raise, and the paycheck barely moves. You pick up extra shifts, and half of it seems to vanish. Then April comes and you owe on top of everything that was already withheld.

Some of that is just what a high income costs. A lot of it isn’t. In our experience, the tax problems physicians bring us are mostly fixable ones, and they tend to be the same handful over and over.

So this article covers two things: how your income is taxed, since a few stubborn myths make the picture look worse than it is, and where physicians most often get tripped up.

How a Physician’s Income Is Taxed

There are seven federal income tax brackets in 2026: 10%, 12%, 22%, 24%, 32%, 35%, and 37%. The top rate applies to taxable income above $640,600 for single filers and $768,700 for married couples filing jointly.

Here’s the myth. A lot of people believe that crossing into a higher bracket means all of their income gets taxed at the higher rate. It doesn’t.

Only the dollars inside each bracket are taxed at that bracket’s rate. Your first dollars are taxed at 10%, the next slice at 12%, and so on up the ladder. A raise can never leave you with less money after federal income tax than you had before it.

Two terms make this easier to talk about.

Your marginal tax rate is the rate on your last dollar of income, which is your top bracket.

Your effective tax rate is your total tax divided by your income. It’s the number that describes what you really pay, and it’s always lower than the marginal rate.

Take a married couple with $400,000 of taxable income. They’re in the 32% bracket. Their federal income tax works out to roughly 20% of that income, because most of their dollars were taxed in the lower brackets on the way up.

Both numbers matter, for different reasons. The effective rate tells you where you stand. The marginal rate tells you what a deduction is worth, since a dollar you deduct comes off the top. That’s why tax planning strategies are worth more to a physician than to almost anyone else.

The Tax Problems Physicians Run Into Most

None of these are exotic. They come from the way physician pay is structured, and payroll systems aren’t built to handle them for you.

Bonuses Are Under-Withheld

When your employer pays a signing bonus, a productivity bonus, or a retention bonus, federal tax is usually withheld at a flat 22%.

If you’re in the 32% or 35% bracket, that leaves a gap of ten points or more on every bonus dollar. On a $50,000 bonus, that’s $5,000 to $6,500 you still owe, and nobody tells you until you file.

Two Incomes, or Two Jobs

Each employer withholds as if its paycheck is your only income. That works for one job. It falls apart with two.

A two-physician household is the classic case. Each paycheck is withheld as though that salary starts at the bottom bracket, but combined, most of the second income lands in the upper brackets. The same thing happens when you change jobs mid-year or work for two employers at once.

There’s also the Additional Medicare Tax, an extra 0.9% on earnings above $200,000 for single filers and $250,000 for married couples. Employers only start withholding it once you pass $200,000 at that one job, so couples and people with two jobs routinely come up short.

The IRS has a free Tax Withholding Estimator that will tell you how far off you are. It takes about fifteen minutes with your pay stubs in hand.

Side Income With Nothing Withheld

Moonlighting, locum shifts, expert witness work, consulting, and medical directorships are often paid on a 1099. That means no tax is taken out at all.

You owe regular income tax on it at your top rate, plus self-employment tax. You’re also expected to send the IRS estimated payments every quarter. Skip them and you’ll pay an underpayment penalty on top of the bill.

The good news is that 1099 income opens doors W-2 income doesn’t, including business deductions and your own retirement plan. Past a certain level it’s worth asking whether you should incorporate.

Deductions That Disappear as You Earn More

This one catches new attendings. Tax breaks you counted on in residency phase out as income rises.

The student loan interest deduction goes away. So does the ability to contribute directly to a Roth IRA, which is why so many physicians use the backdoor Roth and then need to report it correctly on Form 8606. Practice owners find that the 20% deduction for pass-through business income is limited for medical practices once income passes a threshold.

None of this means you did anything wrong. It means the plan that worked at $65,000 doesn’t work at $350,000.

Finding Out in April

The last problem is timing, and it sits underneath all the others.

Most physicians hand a stack of forms to a preparer in March. By then the year is closed and almost nothing can be changed. A preparer records what happened. A planner works with you while there’s still time to change it.

We wrote more about these in how to avoid common physician tax errors.

Are Taxes Higher Than They Used to Be?

“Read my lips: no new taxes.” George H.W. Bush said it in 1988, and some version of that promise has been made in nearly every election since. It lands because most people assume taxes only go one direction.

The history is messier than that.

In 1988 there were just two federal brackets, 15% and 28%. That sounds like a bargain next to today’s 37%. But go back further and the top rate was 91% through the 1950s and into the early 1960s. Very few people paid it on much of their income, but it was the law.

By that longer measure, today’s rates sit toward the low end. The tax law passed in 2025 kept the current brackets in place with no expiration date, so there’s no scheduled increase on the calendar.

No expiration date doesn’t mean they can’t change, though. Congress can rewrite rates whenever it has the votes, and the national debt is now well past $38 trillion. Nobody knows what happens next. Plenty of planners, us included, think it’s reasonable to prepare for the possibility that rates are higher later in your career or in retirement than they are today.

You can’t control what Congress does. You can control how exposed you are to it, and that’s a planning question.

How to Fix Tax Problems Before They Start

Start with the withholding, because it’s the fastest fix. If you got a bonus this year, have a working spouse, or changed jobs, update your W-4. You can ask payroll to withhold an extra flat amount from each check, and that alone ends most April surprises.

If you have 1099 income, set aside a share of every payment the day it arrives and make the quarterly estimates. There’s a safe harbor that protects you from the underpayment penalty: pay in at least 110% of last year’s total tax and you’re covered, even if this year’s income jumps. For a physician whose income is climbing fast, that rule is worth knowing.

Then look at what lowers the tax itself.

Pre-tax retirement contributions are the big one. Every dollar into a 401(k) or 403(b) comes off your income at your top rate. A health savings account does the same if you’re in a qualifying health plan, and it’s the rare account that’s never taxed when used for medical costs.

After that it gets more individual. Charitable giving can be timed. Investment losses can offset gains. Practice owners and physicians with side businesses have a longer list, which we cover in 5 ways for doctors to save on taxes.

One more idea, and it connects back to the uncertainty about future rates. Don’t put everything in one tax bucket. A mix of pre-tax accounts, Roth accounts, and ordinary taxable investments gives you choices about which money to draw on later, whatever the brackets look like by then. It’s a core part of how we approach retirement planning.

If your situation has several of these moving at once, that’s the point where a tax strategist earns their fee.

The Bottom Line

A high income comes with a high tax bill, and no strategy makes that go away. But most of what physicians call tax problems are really planning problems. The withholding was off, or the side income wasn’t accounted for, or nobody looked at the return until the year was over.

Those can be fixed, usually in the same year you spot them.

If you’d like someone to go through your situation with you, get in touch.